YouTube in MyClass
There is much debate among students, teachers, administrators, and even technicians about the education value in YouTube. I, for one, see it as a tremendous resource that, when used properly, brings much needed perspective to lessons. For example, during a seventh grade discussion about the history of technology (remember they were born around 1995) I use a 1950’s “science and technology” video from Unitedstreaming. The video is good, it illustrates how NASA and the military drove technology inovoation for decades. I feel the video provides an excellent historical perspective, but the students response is usually “meh.” However, when I follow the “boring” technology lesson with few retro Nintendo commercials, the room lights up. The students bombard me and each other with comments and requests for more visions of the past.
There are a couple of things that I learned from this. One, YouTube is not the devil. Two, although a distribing image, the age old saying remains true, there is more than one way to skin a cat.
Here are two videos I have used in class. Borrowing a line from Karl Fisch, I use the videos to prompt a discussion about how students are being educated for jobs that don’t exist using technology that hasn’t been invented yet. That is a tough concept for middle school students to understand, especially students living in a stagnate rural area where much of the economy still depends largely on farming, manufacturing, and mining. I am happy to report that they like the videos, but they love the conversation about future possibilities.
Just for fun, here is the Nintendo commercial I love.
Also, I am looking forward to my first NECC and discussing blogging at the edubloggercon.
March 12th, 2007 at 1:52 pm
Have the debaters seen “Web 2.0″ or “Connected Classroom”? I think these Youtubes stop debate in its tracks!
March 12th, 2007 at 2:00 pm
I will be sure to save and share both of thoes. Thanks.
Ken
March 12th, 2007 at 5:27 pm
Great thoughts – I must now quote you “YouTube is not the devil” is my new message to school districts I work with! Thanks.
Chris O’Neal
http://www.edleadersonline.org
March 14th, 2007 at 6:20 pm
Ken, you will absolutely love NECC. This year I have two presentations. One is a hands-on session on interactivity in Power Point Using Triggers and the other is Easy On-line Multimedia. I enjoyed browsing your blog. I agree it is not the technology that is the “devil” but how it is utilized.
LL
April 11th, 2007 at 8:32 pm
Ken! Linda is right…..NECC is fantastic! You’ll love it. There are tons of things to see, the NECC crowd is really friendly, and there are always tons of great workshops and presentations to check out.
Be sure to drop by the Yahoo! Teachers booth and pick up some swag and say “hi”….it would be great to get a chance to meet you in person!
Cheers!
Derek